Hey Joshua!
You're technically not wrong at all. It all depends on the context.
For example, if I were to plot out the C Major Pentatonic & A Minor Pentatonic on the guitar neck, the shapes made would be identical - Because both scales share the same notes.
But whether the sound your making with the shape is treated as a Minor or Major Pentatonic depends on the Harmony or Chord your playing over. It will sound minor over an A minor chord and Major over a C major chord etc. Because the notes you will hit in the scale will have a different relationship to the notes in each chord.
Hope this helps!